Search guide
- 131 Orchard St., Lower East Side 10002
- 212-533-4684
Black Tree Sandwich Shop
Crown Heights favorite opens shop on the Lower East Side. Narrow hall fits old wood, old bricks, and a long, whiskey-stocked bar. Sandwiches run across ethnic lines, from bulgogi to broccoli rabe t... read more
- 75 Ninth Ave., Chelsea 10011
- 212-390-8851
Num Pang
Offshoot of much-loved sammy shop. Technically dishes num pang, not bánh mì, but swipe a page from Tricky Dick: international border, we had no idea! Familiar toasted mini baguettes, ... read more
- 73 Warren St., Tribeca 10007
- 212-791-6300
Mulberry & Vine
It's hard to make spiced pulled pork sandwiches, spicy sesame soba noodles, and chicken enchiladas all that healthy, but Mulberry & Vine attempts this impossibility with its global, local dishe... read more
- 75 Ninth Ave., Chelsea 10011
- 212-255-5672
The Lobster Place
Stalwart of the Chelsea Market gets a new finish. Retail shop sees separate counters for lobsters fresh or steamed. Long steel counter for fresh fish offerings, or get super-fresh with eight-seat o... read more
- 646 Lexington Ave., Midtown East 10022
- 212-838-6000
Clarke's Standard
Storied P.J. Clarke's drops a burger spinoff for those who can't sweat two-hour lunches. Crisp, tall-ceilinged space sees pine beams and white tiled walls. Beef comes from a Pennsylvania farm; topp... read more
- 62 Chelsea Piers, Chelsea 10011
- 212-780-0577
'wichcraft
Baby sib of Craft empire deploys to Chelsea Piers. Cult-fave sandwiches like tuna with fennel, pork with red cabbage, and chopped chickpeas. Health-zone location inspires three unique mens: grill b... read more
- 201 E. Houston St., Lower East Side 10002
- 646-896-1110
Lobster Joint
G-Point and Rockaways seafood shack sensation brings it over to the big town. Joint skews quaint, with picnic tables, whitewashed walls, natural light streaming in through the skylight. Order off t... read more
- 328 E. 14th St., East Village 10003
- 212-228-2807
Chubby Mary's
Sub shop from the pizzaiolos behind Artichoke Basille’s. Little nook with a takeout counter and a mural of a beat-up Rocky hanging with that old lady/young lady illusion. Italian slant with m... read more
- 184 DeKalb Ave., Fort Greene 11205
- 718-596-4147
The Brooklyn Sandwich Society
Former supper club’s brick and mortar establishment. White tiled walls, red leather barstools make for a cozy space. Farm-to-table fare from appetizers onward sees beet salad, tapas-sized Bru... read more
- 19 Kenmare St., Nolita 10012
- 212-219-3434
The Butcher's Daughter
Café and juice bar from Apothéke cocktail guru Heather Tierney. Bright white space, yellow stools, and embellishments from the garden. Brandi Kowalski of ABC Kitchen on the juice menu... read more
- 68 Ave. A, East Village 10009
- 212-466-2860
Croissanteria
Coffee, croissants, and a place to linger. Crisp white hall of a shop adds a velvety church pew along one side for those going into extra innings. Note the big vintage clock on the wall, ignore the... read more
- 208 Columbus Ave., Upper West Side 10023
- 212-874-2929
El Mitote
Quick casual sandwich spot in the old Rigoletto space. Clean little shop, modest hacienda flair. Slow-cooked carnitas fills classic tortas and open-faced, griddle-cooked molettes. Fresh-baked birot... read more
- 55 W. 26th St., Flatiron 10010
- 646-862-9969
Melt Shop
Window-front midtown take-away opens full sit down spot in the Flatiron. Slanted wood paneling and bright yellow chairs right in keeping with sandwich color schemes. Ham and gruyere, a Thanksgiving... read more
- 17 E. 13th St., Greenwich Village 10003
- 212-675-2227
La Maison du Croque Monsieur
Don’t call them paninis. Lovely little sandwich shop offers a dozen sandwiches on sourdough pain de mie. Take out or dine upstairs at a cozy wooden bar. Classics like the Mr. Henry (jambo... read more
- 56 Ave. C, East Village 10009
- 212-777-2277
Bikinis
Trendy Spanish café is a cozy nook of a place, with white brick walls, tangerine bar, and vintage diner tables. Tapas fare and “bikini” sandwiches put together with American ... read more
- 330 W. Broadway, Soho 10013
- 212-226-8111
Salumè
Fine cured meats on fresh baguettes. White-walled space, smattering of tables and chairs for those with time to linger. Several focaccia options, but most paninis served on long crusty loaves... read more
- 195 Fifth Ave., Park Slope 11217
Zito's Sandwich Shoppe
Superior sandwiches and molto-fresh Italian. Rustic space with butcher block tables, subway tiles, roomy backyard. Excels at a baker’s dozen of Italian-American classic sammies; Sicilian tuna... read more
- 463 W. 24th St., Chelsea 10011
- 212-645-5660
Rocket Pig
Awesomely named shop occupies brick shed next to parent Trestle on Tenth. Chef Ralf Kuettel's titular sandwich with smoked pork, onion jam, pickles, and hot sauce already making a major stir. ... read more
- 138 Division St., Lower East Side 10002
Forgtmenot
Fresh garden and grill tucked somewhat randomly on Division Street. Scrapbook kitsch design with slight country-house flair. Salads and sandwiches from chefs of former Souvlaki GR truck. Cheeseburg... read more
Featured Listings
-
Intermix
One-stop shopping with great blend of cutting-edge chic and ready-t...
-
Costata
Michael White of Ai Fiori et al does an Italian steakhouse south of...
-
One Twenty-Two First Avenue
South Brooklyn Pizza peeps wrap a stealth Italian spot around their...
-
Personnel of New York
Kristi Paras of Zachary's Smile re-ups her Village space with a bou...
-
Bonobos
Appointment-only, hour-long guided shopping experience. Second show...
