Search guide
Refine by Location:
Bronx Brooklyn Downtown Manhattan Midtown Manhattan Queens Staten Island Uptown Manhattan
- 122 First Ave., East Village 10009
- 212-533-2809
One Twenty-Two First Avenue
South Brooklyn Pizza peeps wrap a stealth Italian spot around their counter. Follow the hall past artisanal cheese/charcuterie into hidden back room. Rustic brick, fireplaces, and garden atrium pro... read more
- 229 Duffield St., Brooklyn 11201
- 718-254-7813
Brooklyn Brewhouse
Encyclopedic beer list up the road from Barclays. Cozy, mod space with plenty of screens and a light funk soundtrack. Forty bottles joined by fourteen brews on draft. Plenty of fried finger food, p... read more
- 180 Hester St., Little Italy 10013
- 212-334-3811
180 Neapolitan Eatery
Top-shelf pizza on a Little Italy second floor. Cozy speakeasy-style dining space with an open view of thousand-degree oak- and cherrywood-burning oven. Pizzaiolo Salvatore Olivella does Neapolitan... read more
- 535 Hudson St., West Village 10014
- 212-929-2920
Wild
Exactly the kind of pizza place you'd expect from a half-Japanese half-Indian French-Canadian. Crust is vegan and gluten-free, made fresh daily with wild yeast. Toppings favor farm-to-table with lu... read more
- 151 W. 34th St., Garment District 10001
- 212-967-9251
Stella 34 Trattoria
Naples comes to Macy’s Herald Square. Historic 1901 department store at last has a commissary it deserves, with Neapolitan pies, Italian classics, and three wood-burning ovens. Jonathan Benno... read more
- 1600 Amsterdam Ave., Harlem 10031
- 212-926-0580
Coccola
Tomato-red wood-burning oven sourcing both atmosphere and killer Neapolitan pies. Chef’s from Forcella in Naples, cooks classic thin crusts with a deft sear. Smoked mozzarella, prosciutto di ... read more
- 205 Hudson St., Tribeca 10013
- 212-776-1441
American Flatbread Tribeca Hearth
Fancy way of saying “pizza,” but Vermont export takes its dough seriously. Spent almost twenty years in the Green Mountains honing its craft before making the leap to Tribeca. Brings al... read more
- 19 Old Fulton St., Dumbo 11201
- 718-596-6700
Juliana's Pizza
Pizza wars are on and Dumbo is the winner. Patsy Grimaldi, nephew of the Harlem master, returns to his legendary Brooklyn spot. The original coal oven is still there, ready to throw down with nearb... read more
- 128 Metropolitan Ave., Williamsburg 11211
- 718-599-0200
L'isola
Pizza plus gastropub down along the Williamsburg waterfront. Roof deck and rooftop lounge take max advantage of East River proximity. Red pies, white pies, and schiaccate—stuffed brick-oven f... read more
- 364 Atlantic Ave., Boerum Hill 11217
- 718-330-0888
Krescendo
Top/Iron Chef Elizabeth Falkner lights out from Frisco to tackle Brooklyn pizza, then turns things over to able hands. Wood-burning oven imported from Italy takes center stage, produces award-winni... read more
- 8530 Third Ave. , Bay Ridge 11209
- 718-833-0043
Vicolo
Despite Bay Ridge's major repping of the Italian diaspora, serious 'za outside of greasy slices can be hard to source. Enter Vicolo and its stellar Neapolitan pies. Pizzaiolo is Luigi Olivella,... read more
- 289 Fifth Ave., Park Slope 11215
- 347-725-4891
Brooklyn Central
Pizza central. Wood-burning oven bumps the atmosphere, cranks out fresh (and wet) Neapolitan-style pies. Pizzaolos did time at Spotted Pig and I Trulli. Menu divides into Old World classics and New... read more
- 40 N. 6th St., Williamsburg 11211
- 718-218-7045
Fabbrica
Restaurant, coffee shop, and market inside new-school condo The Edge. Main room sees long communal tables and 17-foot ceilings. Name is Italian for factory, reflected in huge murals of machine imag... read more
- 377 Park Ave. So., Gramercy 10016
- 212-448-1116
Forcella
Larger, more Manhattan-y version of Neapolitan spot already lighting it up in Williamsburg. Signature pies from Brooklyn carry over, joined by an expanded menu and a mozzarella bar. Pizzas divide i... read more
- 660 Amsterdam Ave., Upper West Side 10025
- 212-706-7282
Numero 28 Cucina
Village-spawned chainlet builds on pizzeria expertise, brings authentic Southern Italian to the Upper West. Sicilian specialties nod to Neptune’s beat; tuna carpaccio, swordfish carbonara, fr... read more
- 488 Ninth Ave., Midtown West 10018
- 212-273-1181
Tavola
Nicola Accardi converts old Manganaro’s into pizza spot. Oven’s made of volcanic clay from Mount Vesuvius, but they kept the old skylight for New York vibes. Private estate Castelvetran... read more
- 265 Union Ave., Williamsburg 11211
- 718-855-8729
Williamsburg Pizza
Made in Brooklyn and damn proud of it. Focus is on high-quality ingredients, but maybe the “Fresh!” sign up front already alerted you to that. Retro striped awning a callback to parlors... read more
- 214 Hicks St., Brooklyn Heights 11201
- 718-858-1010
Dellarocco's
Heights Café crew puts the focus on classic wood-burning oven pizza next door. Specialty is personal pies, served from lunch to deep in the evening. Neapolitan approach, authentic ingredient... read more
- 685 Franklin Ave., Crown Heights 11238
- 347-955-4881
Rosco's
Chef Jonathan Greenberg (Franny's, Paulie Gee's) gets together with other local heroes to take over neighborhood slice shop. Retro-styled ode to the classic Brooklyn pizza joint. Black vinyl banque... read more
- 10 Devoe St., Williamsburg 11211
- 347-599-2009
Dieci Pizzeria & Osteria
Addition to the East Williamsburg pizza-scape aims to fill void left by dearly departed Motorino. Locavoricious, sustainable pizza ingredients get the wood-burning oven treatment. Braciola stuffed ... read more
Featured Listings
-
Intermix
One-stop shopping with great blend of cutting-edge chic and ready-t...
-
Costata
Michael White of Ai Fiori et al does an Italian steakhouse south of...
-
One Twenty-Two First Avenue
South Brooklyn Pizza peeps wrap a stealth Italian spot around their...
-
Personnel of New York
Kristi Paras of Zachary's Smile re-ups her Village space with a bou...
-
Bonobos
Appointment-only, hour-long guided shopping experience. Second show...
