Search guide
Refine by Bar Type:
Beer Garden Bohemian Clandestine Dive Hotel Bar Karaoke Bar Live Music Lounge Neighborhood Bar Pub More »
- 474 W. Lake Dr., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-8344
Swallow East
Raw bar, tacos, and reggae down on the docks? Yes please. This charter boat adjacent eatery has earned it's stripes and it's staying power in the ever changing Montauk scene. Balances decently good... read more
- 4 S. Elmwood Ave., Montauk 11954
- 631-238-5963
Zum Schneider MTK
With 12 beers on tap (4 of which are served here exclusively) and three sizes for each one ranging from large to ridiculously large, means this place has more steins than lower Manhattan, because p... read more
- 148 South Emerson Ave., Montauk 11954
- 631-647-8000
The Sloppy Tuna
What to say when new owners clean up a neighborhood dive, and the cleaner nicer place goes by the potentially offiensive moniker The Sloppy Tuna? Not much, really. It's a faux-dive beach bar, but t... read more
- 161 Second House Rd., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-2877
Ruschmeyer's
Another dive-y family motel has been reborn into a hipster haven in Montauk: This time it's the Second House Tavern, gloriously transformed into a boutique hotel, restaurant and club complex. In ad... read more
- 90 Second House Rd, Montauk 11954
- 631-668-9739
The Backyard
Out of the way and away from the scene, The Backyard has created one of its own. Restaurant and lounge behind Solé East offers some sort of alternate-reality boho-chic Montauk: A roadside in... read more
- 99 Edgemere Rd., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-5005
O'Murphy's Pub
If Montauk had a Cheers it would be O'Murphy's (except Cliff would be a charter boat captain). Everybody knows owners Chet and Jan, who know everybody. Checked tablecloth (green, of course) tables ... read more
- 401 W Lake Dr., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-9597
Liars' Saloon
Just behind the dock, this dingy bar is in its ideal setting -- the clanging of the boatyard behind it and the salt air making its patrons feel at home. There is, of course, no door policy, but you... read more
- 4 Old West Lake Dr., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-2077
The Crow's Nest Inn & Restaurant
Beloved Montauk classic born again following a major upgrade in service and amenities, as NYC hotelier Sean MacPherson is now running the show at the 18-unit (including two-bedroom cottage) hotel a... read more
- 2167 Montauk Hwy., Montauk 11954
- 631-267-7993
Cyril's Fish House
Arrive early to find a seat and you just might find a companion. Cyril’s serves up satisfying seafood like Cajun calamari and reggae beats to put you in the mood. Depending on the luck of you... read more
- 1 Town Rd. , Montauk 11954
- 631-668-9778
The Dock
Old school Montauk in its purest form. Formerly Fitzgerald's, now seen over by proprietor George Watson, Harbor-side fish shack does what you'd think it would: saloon-style drinking with shellfish,... read more
- 65 Tuthill Rd. , Montauk 11954
- 631-668-2410
Duryea's Lobster Deck
Duryea's has been in the seafood business since the 1920's, so they know a thing or two about gathering, preparing, and serving the bounty of the sea. Take a seat on the outdoor deck and lose yours... read more
- 240 Fort Pond Rd., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-8367
WashOut
The group behind Traffic Bar in NYC stakes out new territory in Montauk. Outdoor bar and wide open floor plan almost make up for the lack of an ocean view. Fairly standard pub food with a few nicel... read more
- 435 E. Lake Dr., Montauk 11954
Moby Dick's
The vibe here is so cool you probably won't even break a sweat. The Surf Lodge is to the meatpacking district what this hip beach bar is to Williamsburg. Lifeguard tower seating, shark head festoon... read more
- 88 Firestone Rd., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-5992
The Montauket
Get here early, maybe even straight from the beach (the brah-dudes and middle-age pervs at the bar won't mind) and settle in for the sinking sun. The out of the way location perched on Fort Pond Ba... read more
- 692 Montauk Hwy., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-2702
Memory Motel
Montauk dive with 70's rock pedigree where Mick and company shot pool when kickin' it at Warhol's spot nearby. Drunkenly slur "Hannahhhhhh" as you get twisted on cheap drinks until your eyes ... read more
Featured Listings
-
BLT Steak at the Capri
Once you've set the bar by having a Nobu outpost residing in your h...
-
Madison & Main
Staking claims in Sag Harbor's culinary arms race, Michael Gluckman...
-
Sienna Restaurant & Ultralounge
Tony Fortuna's TBar Steak & Lounge concept (one that is nearly ...
-
Fresh
To say Fresh has something for everybody isn't a cliché; it'...
-
The Cuddy
The latest from the team behind Sen, this new American Gastropub wi...
