Search guide
Refine by Hotel Type:
Beach Hotel Bed & Breakfast Boutique Hotel Budget Hotel Family-Friendly Hotel Lux Mid-range Weekend Getaway Hotels Wine Country HotelsRefine by Location:
- 55 S. Elmwood Ave., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-2112
The Montauk Beach House
Gone are the days when Montauk existed as a workingman's vacation town, and if you ever saw what this place used to look like, you'd probably wonder why this didn't happen sooner. The faux wood pan... read more
- 11 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island 11965
- 631-749-1633
La Maison Blanche
Sometimes a brand new hotel can feel like an old one in all the right ways. Such is the case here; owners Alistair MacLean (formerly of Andre Balazs' Sunset Beach) and local inn owner John Sieni br... read more
- 281 County Rd., Southampton 11968
- 631-504-6575
Capri
Bringing together a holy trinity of hot hoteliers -- David Edelstein, Jackie Mansfield, and Steven Kamal, separate forces behind W South Beach and Surf Lodge in Montauk -- the all new Capri Hotel h... read more
- 161 Second House Rd., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-2877
Ruschmeyer's
Another dive-y family motel has been reborn into a hipster haven in Montauk: This time it's the Second House Tavern, gloriously transformed into a boutique hotel, restaurant and club complex. In ad... read more
- 23 Windmill Ln., Amagansett 11930
- 631-267-8500
The Reform Club
Sure you've got your design-geek-chic hotels out East, your art minded citizenry, and your pricey pads. And occasionally all of these these things can come together in a quiet cozy town. Such is th... read more
- 183 Edgemere St., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-2632
Surf Lodge
The first in what the hoteliers plan as a brand, the Lodge steals some of Balazs' Sunset Beach thunder with this hip and off-the-high-heel-beaten track in Montauk. Each of the well-apponted bungalo... read more
- 90 Second House Rd., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-2105
Solé East
This boutiquey 60-roomer just off Fort Pond benefits from a recent refresh of an old'20s-era inn. Pretty posh by Montauk standards. Prices remain a little lofty, but amazing what a fresh paint job,... read more
- 57225 Main Rd., North Fork 11971
- 631-765-0177
North Fork Table & Inn
The acclaimed hotel restaurant run by NYC expats serve classic American comforts spun with fresh seasonal dishes using local, organic, biodynamic ingredients (artisinal cheeses, seafood from P... read more
- 326 Front Street, North Fork 11944
- 631-477-0066
Greenporter Hotel
Lug your luggage to the North Fork for a weekend in Long Island wine country. Peapod-mod chalet boasts orchid-accented lobby and 30 guest rooms with contempo/minimalistic décor. A half-dozen... read more
- 2000 Oregon Rd., North Fork 11952
- 631-804-0367
Shinn Estate Vineyard & Farmhouse
Located in a remote farming area of Mattituck, husband and wife David Page and Barbara Shinn grow Bordeaux varietals in an organic, biodynamic way. On-site vegetable farm large enough to feed staff... read more
- 28 Shore Rd., Amagansett 11930
- 631-267-3350
White Sands Resort Hotel
It's tough to argue with being able to walk out of your room and onto sand dunes, and in the Hamptons your chances are few and far between. Your amenities at this modest "resort" consist mainly of ... read more
- 4 Old West Lake Dr., Montauk 11954
- 631-668-2077
The Crow's Nest Inn & Restaurant
Beloved Montauk classic born again following a major upgrade in service and amenities, as NYC hotelier Sean MacPherson is now running the show at the 18-unit (including two-bedroom cottage) hotel a... read more
- 49 Main St., Sag Harbor 11963
- 631-725-3535
The American Hotel
Vintage rules at this century-old Sag Harbor landmark. Victorian fireplaces, mounted moose heads and enough antiques to make your grandmother swoon. Book far in advance, as there are only eight ele... read more
- 2266 Main St., Bridgehampton 11932
- 631-537-3660
Bridgehampton Inn
A classic country escape mere stiletto steps away from Bridgehampton village. Dreamy antique mirrors, four-poster beds, and charm to compensate for lack of flash. Operated by Anna and Detlef Pump, ... read more
- 295 Three Mile Harbor Rd., East Hampton 11937
- 631-324-9191
East Hampton Point
Though it sounds like a spot to park with your date late-night, this is a romantic, waterside resort with an elegant restaurant and full-service marina. Stay in a Palmer House suite with plasma TV,... read more
- 91 Hill St., Southampton 11968
- 631-283-6500
Southampton Inn
Center stage in Southampton village, this Tudor-style inn nestled on prim manicured grounds is more B&B than business casual (though it’s the area’s largest conference facility). Ba... read more
- 272 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk 11954
- 631-668-3000
Panoramic View
There isn't a single room in this joint that doesn't have an oceanfront view. Oh, and that ocean? It's all yours. The beach is for guests only. Lawn chairs and towel service provided. With no bar o... read more
- 143 Main St., East Hampton 11937
- 631-324-3504
The 1770 House
Warmth and welcome extending all the way back to 1770. Contemporary comforts united with colonial charm promises exquisite luxury. Exposed ceiling beams, hardwood floors, crackling fireplaces, and ... read more
- 35 Shore Rd., Shelter Island 11965
- 631-749-2001
Sunset Beach
If the Meatpacking District could go on vacation, it would choose Sunset Beach. European vibe and luxe amenities draw a beach-chic crowd clad head to pedicured-toe in hip resort-wear. Leave the Bla... read more
- 1 Bridgehampton Tpke., Bridgehampton 11932
- 631-537-0870
Topping Rose House
Opening right at the end of the summer season last year, the restaurant at Topping Rose House has already slapped foodies in the mouth with a bit of delicious. Colicchio's cultivated farm-to-table ... read more
Featured Listings
-
BLT Steak at the Capri
Once you've set the bar by having a Nobu outpost residing in your h...
-
Madison & Main
Staking claims in Sag Harbor's culinary arms race, Michael Gluckman...
-
Sienna Restaurant & Ultralounge
Tony Fortuna's TBar Steak & Lounge concept (one that is nearly ...
-
Fresh
To say Fresh has something for everybody isn't a cliché; it'...
-
The Cuddy
The latest from the team behind Sen, this new American Gastropub wi...
